Silencing Military Bloggers
Thursday, May 3rd, 2007Wired News reported yesterday that new rules prevent Army soldiers, contractors and even civilian employees from blogging, sending personal email or other communication via the Internet without prior approval of their commanders. Before the regulations, which took effect April 19, military bloggers were encouraged to seek input from commanders before posting material “that might contain sensitive and/or critical information in a public forum.” but the new rule goes far beyond a common sense guideline intended to protect sensitive military information. It’s prior restraint, pure and simple. See Dadmanly’s blog for an interpretation fo the new regs from a military point of view.
If you’re interested at all in how the Iraq war looks from the point of view of people fighting it, you’ve probably read milblogs. If not, try Black Five and The Mudville Gazette. They offer insights and unvarnished assessments you simply can’t get from conventional media. The new Army regulations could well kill miliblogging.
But these regulations don’t merely affect bloggers: they potentially constrain anyone who sends email to friends and family, posts on MySpace, or uploads Flickr photos. You don’t have to be a blogger to be silenced by these onerous rules. Even if soldiers seek and receive clearance to communicate with the world back home, the requirement to clear every word, picture and YouTube video with a commander will undoubtedly have a chilling effect on speech by military personnel. Aside from the obvious free speech implications, such a heavy-handed regulation will surely do harm to the morale of Army members who have grown accustomed to expressing themselves via the Internet. According to the Wired story, military officials don’t anticipate scrutinizing every blog post and email. So it’s all or nothing. They could censor selectively if they wished to, or simply rule that all blogging is forbidding. And having such regulations in place makes it dead simple to silence soldiers who are critical of the Army.
To be sure, there are tactical plans and activities that should not be compromised via blog or email. The military has an interest in maintaining operational security. But these regulations go far beyond what’s necessary to do that.
-shelly



















